I recently read Sylvia Biu’s article entitled, “Homeschooling is a Bad Idea” on examiner.com. As I read, I was infuriated by some of the claims she tried to make about disadvantages of homeschooling. The article was extremely unprofessional and completely biased. Not only did she not include any sources to back up her position, it seemed like she also did no background research on the topic she was writing about. This could quite possible be one of the worst articles I have ever read by any news organization ever.
Starting off, Mrs. Biu declares that parents have to be a “previous honor student or a genius” in order to give quality education to their children. This is completely untrue. Many homeschoolers use very strict curriculums that clearly lay out everything the child will be taught for the day. Parents don’t have to be geniuses or honor students in order to successfully teach their child, they just have to be able to follow what’s already been planned out for them.
Mrs. Biu continues by saying that homeschooling is only for “severely disabled children or those otherwise unable to attend school for whatever reason”. It is very difficult to make me mad, but when I read that statement, I was extremely offended. Yes, homeschool is an excellent substitution for some disabled children, but it shouldn’t and doesn’t stop there. Homeschooling is an exceptional education method and while it might not be for everyone, it definitely works for a lot of people.
Next, Mrs Biu declares that homeschooling is “retarding a child by isolating him from the outside world”. Not only did she just bash all homeschoolers, she also used a word that offends many of special needs individuals. Homeschoolers are not social introverts. Many homeschoolers have a very active, thriving social life and are not shy at all. They participate in sports, go to dances, and have friends just like everyone else.
Following that she says that homeschoolers are missing the classroom experience and are losing out on being “challenged and encouraged by other students’ curiosity”. Homeschooling allows children’s natural curiosity to thrive. While public schools have to cater to the masses, homeschooling can focus on each child’s educational needs. If a child is struggling with a certain subject, they have the ability to stop and focus on that subject till they have completely mastered it, before moving on.
The next point Mrs. Biu makes is completely irrational. She says that schools are excellent monitors for abused and neglected children and homeschool children have no such oversight. It seems like she is try to infer that homeschooling parents like to beat their children. The only difference between homeschool families and public school families is the education method.
Her final point is that homeschoolers aren't learning healthy life habits. She continues by incorrectly assuming that homeschool children are taught in their pajamas in the middle of the afternoon. This is one of the biggest misconceptions there is about homeschooling. Homeschoolers do NOT just sleep all day and lazily decide when they want to start school. Many homeschoolers have an extremely strict schedule that they adhere to everyday.
I was homeschool my entire life until I reached college and I am, by no means, an idiot or even a social reject like this author tries to portray me as. It blows my mind how someone could write such an article and yet know nothing about it. It’s things like this that gives homeschooling a bad reputation.
Here is the article if you would like to read it for yourself: http://www.examiner.com/brooklyn-parenting-in-new-york/homeschooling-is-a-bad-idea